What next if IVF treatment fails? And what is ICSI?
We have discussed IVF treatment in an earlier article. Many couples in Sri Lanka now turn to this treatment. But the distress when a cycle fails, after so much money and emotional strength has gone into it, is hard to put into words. "Is there something wrong with us?" and "Is it worth doing again?" are questions we are often asked. The aim of this article is to tell you why an IVF cycle fails, what ICSI is, and what to consider before trying again.
The truth you should know first
Even in the best, selected cases, a single IVF cycle succeeds for only about one couple in three. If the woman is under 35, the success rate of one cycle is between 30–40%, and once she is over 40 it falls below 10%. This means that a failed first cycle is nothing unusual — in fact it is what happens to the majority. When two or three cycles are taken together (cumulative success), the success rate rises considerably. So you should think of IVF not as a single cycle but as a course of treatment, a journey.
Why an IVF cycle fails
- Genetic abnormalities of the embryo — this is the main reason. Even an embryo that looks good may have defects in its chromosome make-up. Such an embryo does not implant in the womb, or it miscarries in the early weeks. As the woman gets older, the percentage of embryos with these defects rises quickly. At age 40, more than half of embryos may have such defects.
- Fewer eggs, or eggs of lower quality — only a small number of eggs is obtained because the ovaries do not respond to the hormone injections. The AMH hormone level helps to predict this beforehand.
- Sperm problems — fertilisation fails when the sperm count or the way the sperm function is poor. This is what ICSI is the answer to.
- Problems with the womb — fibroids or polyps bulging into the cavity of the womb, adhesions inside the womb, or the inner lining of the womb not becoming thick enough. The condition hydrosalpinx, in which a fallopian tube is swollen and filled with fluid, also interferes with embryo implantation — this is mentioned in our earlier article.
- Lifestyle — smoking, obesity, and uncontrolled diabetes or thyroid disease lower the success rate.
Sometimes none of these reasons can be found. It is a fact of nature that even when a good embryo is placed in a good womb, pregnancy does not always follow.
What is ICSI?
In ordinary IVF, the eggs and sperm that have been collected are put together in one dish in the laboratory and left to fertilise naturally. In ICSI (Intracytoplasmic Sperm Injection), one selected sperm is put directly into the egg with a very fine needle. ICSI is used when the sperm count is very low, when the sperm move poorly, or when fertilisation did not happen in an earlier IVF cycle. ICSI is also what is done with sperm taken from the testes by an operation. There is no evidence that ICSI gives any extra benefit to a couple with no sperm problem — so not everyone needs ICSI.
What to do after a failed cycle
- Have a review appointment — discuss in detail with your doctor how many eggs were obtained, how many fertilised, what quality the embryos were, and what the lining of the womb was like. What needs to change in the next cycle is decided from this information.
- Find out whether there are frozen embryos — if the embryos left over from the first cycle have been frozen, the next step is easier. The hormone injections and egg collection are not needed again. The success rate of frozen embryo transfer (FET) is the same as with fresh embryos, and sometimes better.
- Ask whether extra tests are needed — if two or more cycles with good embryos have failed, tests such as hysteroscopy, which looks inside the womb, and thyroid and blood-clotting tests are considered.
- Be careful about add-on treatments — there are many extra treatments on the market that are given alongside IVF. For most of them there is not enough evidence that they increase success. When such a treatment is suggested, ask what evidence there is for it.
When to stop?
This is not an easy decision for anyone. But it is important to agree with your doctor beforehand how many cycles you should go up to, taking into account your age, how the ovaries respond, your finances and your emotional strength. Talking about alternatives such as donated eggs or adopting a child is not a failure either. And do not be shy of talking about the emotional strain of this journey — that too is part of the treatment.
A failed IVF cycle is not the end. Many couples have their baby from the second or third cycle. See an experienced doctor and discuss in detail why your cycle failed and what the next steps are.